Permits & People

Poor Performance Dismissal Tanzania: Fair Reason, Fair Process and the Cost of Getting It Wrong

Cover: poor performance dismissal in Tanzania, the fair reason, the Code of Good Practice steps and the CMA exposure
A poor performance dismissal is an incapacity case. The employer carries the burden of proving the standard, the support, the warning and the hearing.
Direct answer

Can an employer in Tanzania dismiss an employee for poor performance? Yes. On the Mainland the employer must prove a fair reason and a fair procedure under sections 38 and 40 of ELRA, Cap. 366 R.E. 2023. The employee must have known a reasonable standard, received guidance, a warning and time to improve, and a meeting before the decision. Failure now costs 6 to 20 months' remuneration.

A poor performance dismissal in Tanzania is one of the hardest terminations to defend. The employer must prove the reason, and the courts read the file closely. Most employers lose these cases on paper, not on merit: no written standard, no proof the warning was served, or no meeting before the decision.

This guide sets out the Mainland rules, how probationers differ, how Zanzibar handles incapacity, and what a failed process costs after the 2025 amendments, with a worked TZS example.

What the law says

The Employment and Labour Relations Act, Cap. 366 R.E. 2023 (ELRA) governs dismissal on the Mainland. We cite the Revised Edition 2023, consolidated on TanzLII to 31 December 2023. From section 12 onward its numbers sit one higher than the 2019 edition. Older awards and articles therefore cite section 37 for unfair termination, which is section 38 here.

Section 38 makes it unlawful to terminate employment unfairly. A termination is unfair unless the employer proves a valid reason, a fair reason related to the employee's conduct, capacity or compatibility or the employer's operational requirements, and a fair procedure. Poor performance falls under capacity. Section 40 puts the burden on the employer: "the employer shall prove that the termination is fair."

The detail of a fair incapacity process sits in the Employment and Labour Relations (Code of Good Practice) Rules, GN No. 42 of 2007. Rule 9(2) says the procedure for incapacity "shall be different" from the misconduct procedure. Rules 17 and 18 deal with poor work performance, and Rule 10 with probation.

The Labour Laws (Amendments) Act, No. 4 of 2025 replaced the old minimum award of twelve months' remuneration with bands from 6 to 24 months. It also bars an employer from starting or continuing a disciplinary matter once it is referred to the CMA or the Court.

Who should read this

This guide is for HR managers, line managers and directors of Mainland employers managing an underperforming employee, including groups with Zanzibar staff or permit holders.

If the problem is a breach of rules, such as absence or dishonesty, that is misconduct, and our disciplinary hearing guide applies. If the role itself is disappearing, read the redundancy procedure guide. For an overview of every termination route, see our employee termination guide.

When is a poor performance dismissal fair?

A poor performance dismissal is fair only if both halves of section 38 are met. The reason must be valid and fair, and the procedure must be fair. The employer proves both, on its own records.

Rule 17 of the Code gives the criteria an arbitrator applies. The Court of Appeal set them out in Tanzania Breweries Limited v. Leo Kobelo, Civil Appeal No. 147 of 2021, decided on 19 February 2024:

The first three points go to the reason. The last two go to fairness. An employer who cannot show a written, measurable standard that the employee received will usually fail at the first step. In Kobelo the Court found the alleged underperformance "remained mere allegation with no proven evidence."

Section 36 limits who can claim. The unfair termination provisions do not apply to an employee with less than six months' employment with the same employer. Notice, leave pay and the certificate of service still apply to that employee.

What does the Code of Good Practice require before dismissal?

Rule 18 sets the process for confirmed employees. We have read Rules 18(5) and 18(6) as quoted by the courts. The earlier subrules are summarised here from the Court of Appeal's reasoning and practitioner commentary, so treat their exact wording as a point to confirm.

StepWhat the Code or the courts requireEvidence to keep
1. Set the standardA reasonable, measurable standard the employee knows (Rule 17)Job description, signed targets, KPI sheet
2. Assess and counselEvaluation, guidance, training or counselling (Rule 18, as summarised)Review notes signed by both sides
3. Warn in writingA warning before termination, even where improvement time is dispensed with (Kobelo)Warning letter and proof of service
4. Allow time to improveA reasonable period; intervals that are too short are unfair (Kobelo)Improvement plan with dates and support given
5. Consider alternativesAnother role or adjusted duties where one existsNote of roles considered and any offer
6. Hold the meetingA meeting before the decision, with a fellow employee or union representative (Rule 18(6))Invitation, minutes, employee's response
7. Decide and notifyWritten notice with reasons and the date (s.42(3))Termination letter and acknowledgment

Rule 18(5) allows the opportunity to improve to be dispensed with in two cases. The first is a manager or senior employee "whose knowledge and experience qualify him to judge whether he is meeting the standards set by the employer". The second is where the skill required is so high that "even an isolated instance of failure to meet the standard may justify termination".

That exception is narrower than it looks. In Kobelo the Court held that "the law, as it stands, requires the employer to issue warning before terminating an employee on poor work performance." Rule 18(5) excuses the improvement period, not the warning.

Alternatives matter for money as well as fairness. Under section 43(3)(b), an employee terminated for capacity who unreasonably refuses alternative employment with the employer loses severance pay. A documented offer of a suitable role protects the employer twice.

How are probationers treated differently?

Rule 10 of the Code governs probation. The Court of Appeal in David Nzaligo v. National Microfinance Bank PLC, Civil Appeal No. 61 of 2016, quoted Rule 10(2): "Terms of probation shall be made known to the employee before the employee commences employment."

Practitioner summaries of Rule 10 report a maximum probation of twelve months. They also report duties to monitor and evaluate performance, to meet the employee at regular intervals, and to notify any concern and hear a response. Before termination the probationer should have had a chance to improve. We have not read those subrules in the Gazette text, so confirm them before relying on the detail.

PointProbationerConfirmed employee
Governing ruleRule 10, GN 42 of 2007Rules 17 and 18, GN 42 of 2007
Unfair termination claimBarred under s.36 if under six months' employmentAvailable after six months
ConfirmationNot automatic on expiry of probation (Nzaligo)Already confirmed
ProcessNotify concern, hear response, allow time to improveFull Rule 18 process, warning and meeting
Notice7 days in the first month, then s.42(1) periods28 days for monthly-paid staff
SeveranceNot due under 12 months' service7 days' basic wage per completed year

In Nzaligo the Court held that section 36 "addresses the period of employment and not the status of employment." An employee still on probation after six months' service may therefore have more protection than the label suggests. Our probation period guide covers confirmation letters and extensions.

How is poor performance different from ill health or misconduct?

Practitioner summaries of the Code report that Rule 15(1) recognises three forms of incapacity: ill health, injury and poor work performance. The three share the capacity label but not the process.

Ill health is not a performance problem. Section 33 gives at least 126 days' sick leave in a leave cycle, the first 63 days on full wages and the next 63 on half wages. Dismissing a certified sick employee within that entitlement invites a claim, and section 38 prohibits termination on grounds of disability. The Code has separate ill-health rules, which we have not read in full. Our sick leave guide covers the entitlement.

Misconduct is about choice, not ability. An employee who can meet the standard but refuses is a conduct case, heard under Rule 13 with an investigation first. Mixing the two is a common error. A charge sheet that alleges "negligence" for missed targets usually fails both tests.

What does the incapacity hearing look like?

Rule 18(6) provides that, before finalising a decision to terminate for poor work performance, "the employer shall call a meeting with the employee, who shall be allowed to have a fellow employee or trade union representative present to provide assistance". The High Court applied that rule in Al-Rahma Development Complex v. Miza Abdallah Ukasha, Labour Revision No. 355 of 2022, on 3 March 2023.

In that case the employer relied on student feedback and examination results, with no job description or agreed assessment system. It also held no Rule 18(6) meeting. The Court upheld the CMA's finding of unfair termination on both grounds.

A sound meeting follows a short pattern:

Once a matter is referred to the CMA or the Court, the new section 38(6) bars the employer from starting or continuing a disciplinary matter on it. Finish the process before any referral, and do not reopen it while a dispute is pending.

What goes in the termination letter and final pay?

Section 42(3) requires written notice stating the reasons and the date the notice is given. For a monthly-paid employee after the first month, section 42(1) sets at least 28 days. Section 42(5) allows pay in lieu of notice equal to what the employee would have earned in the notice period.

Section 45 lists what is due on termination: pay for work done, accrued annual leave pay, notice pay, severance pay where due, and any transport allowance. Section 45(2) requires the prescribed certificate of service. Section 32(10) calculates pro rata leave at one day's basic wage for every 13 days worked or entitled to be worked.

Severance under section 43 is at least 7 days' basic wage for each completed year of continuous service, up to ten years, once the employee has 12 months' service. Section 43(3) excludes a fair misconduct dismissal, but not a capacity dismissal. A poor performance dismissal therefore carries severance, unless the employee unreasonably refused an alternative role.

Section 44 adds transport to the place of recruitment where the employee was recruited elsewhere. Run the final pay through the payroll compliance desk so PAYE and contributions are deducted correctly.

What happens when the employee is a foreign national?

The Non-Citizens (Employment Regulation) Act, Cap. 436 adds duties when a permit holder's employment ends. Section 16(2) requires the employer to "immediately report the cessation to the Labour Commissioner." Section 14(1)(b) allows the Labour Commissioner to cancel a permit where the holder ceases the employment it was issued for.

Section 16(1) requires returns on non-citizen employment every 30 June and 31 December. Section 16(3) sets a late penalty of TZS 500,000 for each month or part of a month (register NEW-04-39). Section 17(3) requires a departing holder to surrender the permit within fourteen days before departure.

The fairness rules are the same for a foreign employee. A replacement non-citizen needs a new permit, so budget the fee early. Our work and residence permits service handles the reporting and any replacement file.

What does the Zanzibar law say?

ELRA applies on the Mainland. Zanzibar has its own Employment Act, No. 11 of 2005. Section 3(1) defines "fair reasons" as a justification for dismissal on "misconduct, incapacity and operational requirements", and "fair procedure" as a pre-dismissal procedure on each.

PointMainland (ELRA Cap. 366 R.E. 2023)Zanzibar (Employment Act No. 11 of 2005)
Fair reasonCapacity under s.38Incapacity under s.3(1); termination for incompetency under s.52(1)(e), with reasons under s.52(2)
ProbationRule 10 of GN 42 of 2007Six months, extendable by up to six; deemed confirmed without a letter (s.60)
Notice28 days for monthly-paid staff (s.42)Two weeks after six months, one month after twelve months, three months after five years (s.54(3))
Certificate of services.45(2)s.79, signed and sealed, in English or Kiswahili
Unfair termination and remediesss.38 to 41, as amended in 2025ss.118 to 120; text and award levels to confirm
First dispute stepCMA within 30 daysLabour officer mediation within 21 days (s.21(2)); referral time limit to confirm

Zanzibar also allows termination on medical grounds after sick leave runs out (s.69(2)(c)) and where a medical board certifies incapacity (s.52(1)(d)). A Mainland process or CMA award does not carry over. Work permits in Zanzibar are also separate; see our Zanzibar work permit guide.

How long does the employee have to go to the CMA, and what can it award?

Rule 10(1) of the Labour Institutions (Mediation and Arbitration) Rules, GN No. 64 of 2007, requires a dispute about the fairness of a termination to be referred to the CMA "within thirty days from the date of termination or the date that the employer made a final decision to terminate or uphold the decision to terminate". Other disputes have sixty days under Rule 10(2).

The Court of Appeal applied that limit strictly in CRDB Bank PLC v. Lusekelo Mwakapala, Civil Appeal No. 143 of 2021, on 22 September 2023. A late referral without a determined condonation application left the CMA without jurisdiction. The CMA charges no published referral fee (register F0452).

Section 41(1) lets the arbitrator order reinstatement, re-engagement or compensation. Act No. 4 of 2025 substituted the compensation paragraph, which is section 40(1)(c) in its R.E. 2019 numbering and section 41(1)(c) in R.E. 2023.

Termination found unfair forCompensation band
Unfair procedure only6 to 12 months' remuneration
Unfair reason12 to 18 months' remuneration
Both unfair procedure and unfair reason12 to 20 months' remuneration
Discrimination or harassment12 to 24 months' remuneration

The TanzLII consolidation still shows the old text, "not less than twelve months remuneration", because it predates the 2025 Act. Section 41(3) separately requires twelve months' wages where an employer refuses an order to reinstate. Our CMA guide for employers covers mediation, arbitration and revision.

What do the courts look for?

Three decisions show the pattern. Each turns on evidence the employer could have created at the time.

A performance case is won before the hearing, through signed targets, dated reviews and served warnings.

Worked example: a team leader dismissed for poor performance in Dar es Salaam

A Mainland logistics company employs a customer service team leader on a permanent contract. Her basic wage is TZS 1,800,000 a month, with no allowances, and she works five days a week. She has 4 years and 7 months' service and 15 days of accrued, untaken leave. After a documented Rule 18 process, she is dismissed for poor performance and paid in lieu of notice.

The First Schedule to ELRA converts a monthly wage by dividing by 4.333 for a weekly rate. For a daily rate it divides by 4.333 times the days ordinarily worked each week, here 21.665.

ItemBasisAmount (TZS)
Weekly basic rate1,800,000 / 4.333415,417
Daily basic rate1,800,000 / 21.66583,083
Pay in lieu of 28 days' notice4 weeks x 415,417 (s.42(5))1,661,666
Severance7 days x 4 completed years x 83,083 (s.43)2,326,333
Accrued leave pay15 days x 83,083 (s.32)1,246,250
Terminal package, before wages earned and PAYESum of the three items5,234,249

Where the contract says "one month", pay the full TZS 1,800,000. Wages for days worked in the final month are added, and PAYE is withheld under register bands F0176 to F0180.

Now assume the employer skipped the warning and the Rule 18(6) meeting. The CMA finds the procedure unfair, so the band is 6 to 12 months' remuneration: TZS 10,800,000 to 21,600,000. If it also finds the standard unproven, the band is 12 to 20 months: TZS 21,600,000 to 36,000,000. Unpaid terminal benefits remain due on top of either award.

A few weeks of documented process protects against an award of up to seven times the terminal package.

What to do now

  1. Write the standard. Put measurable targets in the job description or a signed objectives sheet, and keep the employee's acknowledgment.
  2. Review on a fixed rhythm. Hold dated reviews, record the shortfall in numbers, and note the support, training or tools offered.
  3. Warn in writing. Issue a warning that names the standard, the gap, the support and the review date, and keep proof of service.
  4. Give real time. Set an improvement period long enough to show a result in that role, and avoid intervals of a few days.
  5. Look for alternatives. Record any suitable role you considered or offered, because a refusal affects severance under s.43(3)(b).
  6. Hold the Rule 18(6) meeting. Invite the employee in writing, allow a fellow employee or union representative, and decide after the meeting.
  7. Issue the letter and pay. Give written notice with reasons and the date, pay the s.45 items, and issue the certificate of service.
  8. Report foreign staff. Report a permit holder's cessation to the Labour Commissioner immediately, and file the half-yearly return on time.
  9. Diary the 30 days. Note the CMA referral window from the termination date, and route any referral to an advocate at once.

Key dates and deadlines

EventTime limitSource
Unfair termination protection beginsAfter 6 months' employmentELRA s.36
Maximum probation12 months, as reportedGN 42 of 2007, Rule 10(4)
Severance qualifies12 months' continuous serviceELRA s.43(2)
Notice, monthly-paid employeeAt least 28 daysELRA s.42(1)
Termination dispute to CMA30 days from termination or final decisionGN 64 of 2007, Rule 10(1)
Other disputes to CMA60 daysGN 64 of 2007, Rule 10(2)
Report a non-citizen's cessationImmediatelyCap. 436 s.16(2)
Non-citizen employment returns30 June and 31 DecemberCap. 436 s.16(1)
Zanzibar labour officer mediationWithin 21 daysEmployment Act No. 11 of 2005, s.21(2)

What government charges can arise?

A poor performance dismissal carries few government fees, but the foreign-staff lines are costly when missed. Government charges are paid to the authority against its control number at the official rate. They are separate from Zatra's professional fee, which we quote in writing before work starts.

How Zatra helps

Our HR consulting desk builds the performance file: job descriptions with measurable standards, review templates, warning letters, improvement plans, the Rule 18(6) invitation and the termination letter. We also run the terminal pay calculation and the certificate of service.

For foreign staff we prepare the cessation report and half-yearly returns. For tighter performance clauses, see our employment contracts and workplace policies guide and the fixed-term contract guide.

Zatra prepares and coordinates. Representation at the CMA or the Labour Court, a formal legal opinion, and any live dispute go to an advocate, either on our team or the client's own. Zatra does not decide or guarantee any authority's outcome. If an employee resigns during the process instead, our employee resignation guide sets out the exit file.

Sources and status

Accurate as at 16 Nov 2026.

Figures to confirm before you act

This article is general information based on official sources available at the date of publication. It is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and notices change. Verify with the issuing authority or consult Zatra before acting.

Frequently asked questions

Can an employer dismiss for poor performance without any warning?

Rarely. The Court of Appeal held in 2024 that a warning is required before a poor performance termination, even where the improvement period may be dispensed with for a senior employee. Without a served warning, expect a finding of procedural unfairness and an award of 6 to 12 months' remuneration.

Does a performance improvement plan have to be in writing?

No statute uses the term, but the employer carries the burden of proof under section 40. An oral plan is hard to prove. A signed plan with targets, support, review dates and the consequence of failure is the best evidence that the employee knew the standard and had a fair opportunity.

Can missed targets be charged as misconduct instead?

Only where the employee could meet the standard and chose not to, for example by refusing a lawful instruction. Where the employee is trying but cannot perform, it is incapacity. Charging inability as misconduct usually fails, because the misconduct procedure and the evidence do not fit the facts.

What if the employee refuses a lower role offered instead of dismissal?

The employer may still proceed with the dismissal if the process was fair. Under section 43(3)(b), an employee terminated for capacity who unreasonably refuses alternative employment loses severance pay. Whether a refusal is unreasonable depends on the pay, status and location of the role, so record the offer and the reasons for refusal.

Can an employee bring a lawyer to the Rule 18(6) meeting?

The Code gives the right to a fellow employee or trade union representative. It does not give a right to outside counsel at the internal meeting. An employer may allow one by policy. Representation at the CMA is a separate matter, and employers should have an advocate there.

Can the employee later claim a forced resignation over performance pressure?

Yes. Section 37 treats a resignation caused by intolerable conditions as a termination by the employer. A performance process run with humiliation, threats or impossible targets can be recast as constructive termination. Keep the process professional, documented and private.

How long should the performance file be kept?

At least until the CMA referral window has closed and any dispute, revision or appeal is finished. Many employers keep the full file for several years with the payroll records, because a late referral can still be allowed on condonation.

Sources & regulators

Verify before filing: Rates, forms and thresholds move by Finance Act, Government Notice and portal revision. Confirm the live schedule on the mandate-holder portal before you budget or submit. Law-firm alerts and Big Four notes are discovery only.

Brief the desk

This Insights page is orientation. HR Consulting in Tanzania is the commercial desk for the same facts. Zatra’s fee stays on its own line, separate from government, bank and regulator charges. Approvals are not guaranteed.

Book a 20-minute file check Talk to Zatra

+255 788 466 212 · [email protected] · WhatsApp +255 747 912 965

Disclaimer

This article is informational orientation. It is not legal, tax or investment advice and not a government decision. Tanzanian instruments move by Act, Government Notice, Finance Act and portal revision. If a sentence here disagrees with the live mandate-holder, the mandate-holder wins. Zatra Consultants Limited does not issue licences, permits, tax clearances or approvals, and gives no assurance of any regulatory or banking outcome. Professional fees are published only on /pricing/.

Office Line +255 788 466 212
Ask Senior Desk on WhatsApp