Mining Licence Application Rejected Tanzania: Appeals, Judicial Review and Reapplication

What can you do when a mining licence application is rejected in Tanzania? Read the rejection notice first. The Mining Act, Cap. 123 lets the Mining Commission refuse an application on listed grounds, such as default on another mineral right, a conflicting right over the area or weak financial and technical resources. Most refusals are cured by fixing the defect and reapplying. Where the decision itself is unlawful, an advocate can seek judicial review in the High Court.
A mining licence application rejected in Tanzania is rarely the end of the project. It is a decision of the Mining Commission, made under listed grounds in the Mining Act, Cap. 123, and it usually names the defect. Some defects can be fixed in weeks. Others mean the applicant was never eligible in the form it applied.
This guide explains why the Commission rejects applications, what the law says about notice and reasons, when a challenge makes sense, and how reapplying affects your priority over the ground. It covers the prospecting licence (PL), the primary mining licence (PML), the mining licence (ML) and the special mining licence (SML). A worked example prices a rejected 5 km2 gold ML and its replacement.
Section numbers below follow the revised text of Cap. 123 as at 30 November 2019 on TanzLII. Later revisions renumbered parts of the Act, so confirm each pinpoint before you cite it in a filing.
What changed
The legal grounds for refusing an application have not moved in 2026. The enforcement climate has. In April 2026 the Minister for Minerals announced the cancellation of 40 prospecting licences covering 188,163 acres, and default notices on 43 more rights, according to Mwananchi on 15 April 2026. The reasons given were idle ground, unpaid fees, weak local participation and missing expenditure records.
Cancelled ground returns to the pool, and new applications follow. Regional offices are processing large volumes. In Nkasi District alone, the Rukwa resident mining officer reported 74 small-scale gold licences issued and 366 applications in process in October 2026, as JamhuriMedia reported on 13 October 2026.
More applications over freed ground means more competing filings, more overlap refusals and more applicants who held a defaulted right somewhere else. A refusal now often traces back to the applicant's record on another licence, not to the new file.
What the law says about refusing an application
The Mining Act, Cap. 123 applies to Tanzania Mainland, as section 2 states. Section 22 gives the Mining Commission the function to issue licences under the Act and to issue, suspend and revoke exploration and exploitation licences. The Mining Commission therefore decides almost every application, through its headquarters in Dodoma and the resident mine offices.
The Act frames the decision as a duty to grant unless a ground applies. For a mining licence, section 50(1) requires the Commission to grant a properly made application unless a listed ground exists. For a PML, section 55(1) works the same way. The grounds are limited. The Commission cannot refuse for a reason the Act does not give, and that limit is the base of any later challenge.
Three procedural rules matter most.
- For an SML, section 42(3) bars rejection for default unless the Commission first serves a notice of the default and allows a reasonable time to remedy it.
- For an SML rejected for failing the grant criteria, section 42(4) requires a notice giving full particulars of the respects in which the applicant fails.
- For an SML offer, section 42(6) treats the application as lapsed if the applicant does not accept the proposed licence within sixty days of service of the notice.
For prospecting licences, the revised Act requires the licensing authority to give reasons when it rejects an application. For an ML and a PML, the text we read lists the grounds but sets no separate notice period. Section 65(2) says procedures for complaints and appeals are prescribed in regulations. The Mining (Mineral Rights) Regulations, 2018 are the principal regulations, amended among others by GN No. 937 of 2020, which added the ML and SML application forms.
Who is affected
This guide is for four groups.
- Tanzanian individuals, partnerships and companies refused a PML, often over overlap with another right or a reserved area.
- Exploration companies refused a PL, or refused a renewal, because of an unpaid rent or a missing expenditure report.
- Developers converting a PL into an ML or SML, where the feasibility study, local content plan or financing statement did not satisfy the Commission.
- Foreign investors who applied for a PML through a company that does not meet the citizen ownership rule.
It also matters to lenders and buyers. A rejected application can still appear in diligence searches of the cadastre, and a buyer needs to know whether the ground is free, contested or under challenge.
Why are mining licence applications rejected?
The grounds in sections 50(1) and 55(1) fall into a few families. The table pairs each with the usual fix.
| Ground in the Act | Typical facts | Usual response |
|---|---|---|
| Applicant in default on another mineral right (s.50(1)(d); s.55(1)(a)) | Unpaid annual rent, missing reports or an unremedied default notice on a different licence | Cure the old default, get written confirmation, then reapply |
| Conflicting mineral right over the area (s.50(1)(e)(i); s.55(1)(b)) | Coordinates overlap a live PL, PML or ML, or an earlier registered application | Redraw the area on the cadastre, or negotiate with the holder; dispute route if the overlap is wrong |
| Area reserved or under tender (s.55(1)(b)) | Ground set aside for PMLs or offered by tender | Apply in the tender, or choose other ground |
| Inadequate financial and technical resources (s.50(1)(e)(v)) | Thin balance sheet, no named technical team, no credible funding plan | Add parent guarantees, bank letters and a technical services agreement |
| Applicant disqualified (s.8) | A PML company with a foreign shareholder or director | Restructure the ownership; reapplying unchanged will fail again |
| Incomplete application (s.49(2)) | Missing feasibility study, local content plan, procurement plan or integrity pledge | Complete the file and reapply |
Section 49(2) lists what an ML application must contain. It includes a feasibility study, a plan on employment and training of Tanzanians with a succession plan for expatriates, a statement of financial and technical resources, a procurement plan, an integrity pledge and a local content plan. A missing item is the commonest avoidable refusal.
The PML has its own trap. Section 8(2) bars a PML to a company unless its members and directors are all Tanzanian citizens and it is controlled from within Tanzania by citizens. A refusal on that ground is not a paperwork problem. See our primary mining licence guide before you restructure.
Is there an appeal against a rejected application?
Not in the form most applicants expect. Section 65(1), in the 2019 text, gives a person aggrieved by a Commission decision to suspend or cancel a mineral right sixty days to apply to the High Court for judicial review. It speaks of suspension and cancellation. It does not mention refusal of a fresh application.
That leaves four routes for a refused applicant.
- Ask for reasons and reconsideration. Write to the Commission, cite the ground in the notice, and show that it is cured or was wrong. Many refusals over documents or overlap are resolved here.
- Use the complaints procedure. Section 65(2) contemplates complaint and appeal procedures in regulations. Ask the Commission which procedure it applies to your licence class.
- Take a dispute to the Commission. Where the refusal rests on a competing claim to the same ground, section 119 lets the Commission decide disputes, and section 121 provides an appeal to the High Court.
- Seek judicial review. Where the Commission acted outside its grounds, ignored a required notice or decided unfairly, an advocate can apply to the High Court.
Our general guide to licence refusal and revocation compares these forums across regulators. For a right that was granted and later cancelled, read mining licence cancellation instead, because the sixty-day clock in section 65(1) applies there.
How does judicial review work for a refused mineral right?
Judicial review tests how the decision was made, not whether the ground is rich. The court asks whether the Commission acted within the Act, followed fair procedure and reached a decision a reasonable regulator could reach. It does not grant the licence. The usual remedy is an order quashing the refusal and sending the file back.
The procedure sits in the Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Judicial Review Procedure and Fees) Rules, 2014, GN No. 324 of 2014. Rule 5 requires leave of the court before an application for judicial review is made. Rule 6 bars leave unless the application for leave is made within six months after the decision complained of.
Six months is an outer limit, not a target. Delay weakens the case, and the ground may be granted to someone else in the meantime. A court asked to quash a refusal after another applicant holds a licence over the area faces a harder question than one asked within weeks.
Judicial review is litigation. It belongs to an advocate from the first letter. Zatra prepares the factual file and the cadastre record, and the advocate drafts the chamber summons, statement and affidavit.
Should you reapply or challenge the decision?
Reapply when the defect is yours and curable. Challenge when the defect is the Commission's and costly to accept. Most cases fall in the first group.
| Situation | Reapply | Challenge |
|---|---|---|
| Missing or weak document | Yes, after completing the file | Rarely worth it |
| Default on another licence | Yes, after curing the default | Only if the default was wrongly recorded |
| Overlap with a live right | Yes, over redrawn coordinates | If the cadastre record is wrong or the other right has lapsed |
| Refusal on a ground the Act does not list | Possible, but it may be refused again | Yes, with an advocate |
| SML default rejection without prior notice | Possible | Yes; section 42(3) requires notice first |
| PML refused for foreign ownership | Only after restructuring | No; the Act bars the grant |
Both routes can run together. An applicant can lodge a corrected application to protect its place while an advocate tests the first decision. Discuss this with the advocate, because the court may ask why the applicant accepted the process by reapplying.
What happens to priority over the area when you reapply?
Priority is the hidden cost of a refusal. Section 14(1) gives the mineral right to the person whose application was first registered, provided that person is not disqualified under section 8 and is otherwise entitled to the grant. Applications received on the same day are treated as simultaneous, and the licensing authority decides priority between them under the regulations.
A rejected application loses its place. A fresh application is registered on its own date. If a competitor filed over the same ground after your first application but before your second, the competitor may now rank first. That is the main reason to fix and refile fast, and the main reason a wrongful refusal can be worth challenging.
Before refiling, search the register for applications lodged over the area since your first filing. The Mining Commission cadastre portal shows live rights and applications. Our online mining cadastre guide explains the search, and our note on overlapping mineral claims covers ground that two parties both claim.
What fees are lost on a rejected application?
Treat the application fee as spent. The Mining (Mineral Rights) Regulations print separate application, preparation and rent charges. The preparation fee and first rent fall due on grant, so a refused applicant has usually paid only the application fee. We could not confirm any refund rule for an application fee after refusal.
| Register ID | Charge | Amount as printed | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| F0621 | ML application; preparation; annual rent (metallic minerals) | USD 2,000 (TZS 4,500,000); USD 1,000 (TZS 2,300,000); USD 3,000 (TZS 6,800,000) per km2 | GN 1 of 2018, First Schedule, as substituted by GN 47 of 2018 |
| F0621 | SML application; preparation | USD 5,000 (TZS 11,300,000); USD 2,000 (TZS 4,500,000) | Same |
| F0619 | PML application; preparation | TZS 50,000; TZS 50,000 | GN 1 of 2018, as amended by GN 741 of 2019 |
| F0615 | PL application (metallic minerals); preparation | USD 300 (TZS 700,000); USD 300 | GN 1 of 2018, as substituted by GN 47 of 2018 |
| NEW-06-16 | Search in the register | USD 50 (TZS 130,000) per hour | GN 1 of 2018, First Schedule |
These are the fees the instruments print, as carried in Zatra's government fee register. Each is paid to the Commission against its control number, and the amount on the control number governs on the day of payment. High Court filing fees for judicial review are set by the 2014 Rules and are assessed by the registry.
Worked example: a rejected 5 km2 gold mining licence
A Tanzanian company with a foreign parent holds a PL over gold ground and applies for a 5 km2 ML. It pays the USD 2,000 application fee. The Commission refuses on two grounds. First, part of the area overlaps a PML granted to a local group. Second, the financing statement is a single page with no lender or parent commitment.
The company decides to reapply over a redrawn 4 km2 area that excludes the PML. It adds a parent guarantee and a bank letter. It runs a three-hour register search first to confirm that no one filed over the redrawn area.
| Item | Register ID | USD | TZS as printed |
|---|---|---|---|
| First application fee (sunk) | F0621 | 2,000 | 4,500,000 |
| Register search, 3 hours | NEW-06-16 | 150 | 390,000 |
| Second application fee | F0621 | 2,000 | 4,500,000 |
| Preparation fee on grant | F0621 | 1,000 | 2,300,000 |
| First annual rent, 4 km2 at USD 3,000 | F0621 | 12,000 | 27,200,000 |
| Total government charges | 17,150 | 38,890,000 |
The refusal cost USD 2,000 in fees and the search cost USD 150. The larger cost is time. If the redrawn file takes eight weeks to prepare, the project loses eight weeks of its schedule, and it carries the risk that a competitor files first. Redrawing the area also cut annual rent from USD 15,000 for 5 km2 to USD 12,000 for 4 km2.
The TZS column repeats the equivalents the register prints. Pay whatever the control number shows. Advocate and Zatra professional fees are separate from these government charges and are quoted on their own invoice.
For example, suppose the company had believed the overlap was wrongly recorded. It would have asked an advocate to write to the Commission within days and prepare a judicial review file. Meanwhile it would have lodged the redrawn application to protect its place.
What do ML and SML applicants owe the State after grant?
A file rebuilt after refusal must still satisfy the conditions that follow grant. Section 10(1) gives the Government not less than a sixteen percent non-dilutable free carried interest in a company holding an ML or SML. Section 47(a) and section 52(a) require mining to start within eighteen months of grant for an SML and an ML. Royalty, the inspection fee and local content obligations follow production.
An applicant that cannot live with these terms should know before it reapplies. Our mining licence guide covers the ML and SML terms, and our local content ownership note covers the ownership checks the Commission now runs on contractors.
Disputes under the mining agreement itself are a separate track. The Natural Wealth and Resources (Permanent Sovereignty) Act, Cap. 449 keeps disputes over natural resources in Tanzanian forums unless an agreement falls within the Cabinet exception added in 2026. Our post on natural resources arbitration explains that change. A licence refusal is reviewed by the High Court, not by an arbitral tribunal.
Mainland and Zanzibar
Cap. 123 applies to Tanzania Mainland. The Mining Commission, the cadastre portal and the fee schedule above are Mainland instruments. The Ministry of Minerals sets policy for the Mainland sector.
Zanzibar regulates its minerals under its own law and its own ministry. A refusal by a Zanzibar authority follows Zanzibar procedure, and a Mainland judicial review does not reach it. We could not confirm the current Zanzibar statute, the licensing body or the review route for this guide. Treat any Zanzibar refusal as a separate file and ask the Zanzibar authority for its written procedure first.
What to do now
- Read the notice. Identify the exact ground cited and the section it rests on, and diarise the date of the decision.
- Search the register. Check the cadastre for rights and applications lodged over the area since your first filing.
- Classify the defect. Decide whether it is yours and curable, or the Commission's and contestable, using the tables above.
- Cure old defaults. Pay outstanding rent and file missing reports on any other licence, and get written confirmation.
- Brief an advocate early. If the refusal may be unlawful, instruct an advocate within weeks, well inside the six-month leave limit.
- Rebuild the file. Complete every item in section 49(2), including the local content plan, procurement plan and financing statement.
- Refile and track. Lodge the corrected application, pay against the control number and keep the registration receipt as proof of priority.
Key dates
| Period | What it governs | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Same day | Applications received on one day rank as simultaneous | Cap. 123 s.14(2) |
| 30 days | Default remedy period after a default notice, unless extended | Cap. 123 s.63(2)(b) |
| 60 days | Acceptance of a proposed SML before the application lapses | Cap. 123 s.42(6) |
| 60 days | Judicial review against suspension or cancellation of a right | Cap. 123 s.65(1) |
| 6 months | Outer limit to seek leave for judicial review | GN 324 of 2014, r.6 |
| 18 months | Start of mining after grant of an ML or SML | Cap. 123 ss.47(a), 52(a) |
How Zatra helps
Zatra's sector permits and licensing team reads the refusal notice, runs the cadastre search, rebuilds the application file and lodges the corrected application. Where ownership blocks a PML, our company changes team handles the BRELA filings. Government charges are paid at the official rate to the Commission against its control number. They are kept separate from Zatra's professional fee.
Judicial review, disputes before the Commission, legal opinions for lenders, and any seizure or prosecution go to an advocate. Zatra has an advocate on the team. Zatra prepares and files; it does not decide or guarantee any authority's outcome.
Sources and status
Accurate as at 15 November 2026.
- Mining Act, Cap. 123, revised text. TanzLII, version as at 30 November 2019. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Judicial Review Procedure and Fees Rules, GN No. 324 of 2014. Laws.Africa, as published in 2014. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Mining (Mineral Rights) (Amendment) Regulations, 2020, GN No. 937. Geological Survey of Tanzania, 23 October 2020. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Mining (Mineral Rights) Regulations, 2018. UNEP LEAP legislation record, 2018. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Natural Wealth and Resources (Permanent Sovereignty) Act, Cap. 449. TanzLII, version as at 14 July 2021. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Mining Commission home page and news list. Mining Commission, 14 November 2026. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Online mining cadastre portal. Mining Commission, 2026. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Ministry of Minerals home page. Ministry of Minerals, 2026. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Serikali yafuta leseni 40 za madini, yatoa onyo. Mwananchi, 15 April 2026. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
- Leseni 74 za dhahabu zatolewa Nkasi, maombi 366 yachakatwa. JamhuriMedia, 13 October 2026. Accessed 15 Nov 2026.
Figures to confirm before you act
- Section numbers in the current revised edition of Cap. 123, since this guide cites the 2019 revised text.
- Whether the Mining (Mineral Rights) Regulations set a complaint or appeal procedure for refused applications, and its time limit.
- The time limit for an appeal to the High Court from a Commission dispute decision under section 121.
- The period within which the licensing authority must give reasons for rejecting a prospecting licence application.
- Whether any application fee is refunded after refusal.
- The ML, SML, PML and PL fees (F0621, F0619, F0615) and the search fee (NEW-06-16) on the control number on the day you pay.
- The High Court filing fees for leave and for the judicial review application under GN 324 of 2014.
- The current Zanzibar minerals statute, licensing body and review route.
This article is general information based on official sources available at the date of publication. It is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and notices change. Verify with the issuing authority or consult Zatra before acting.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Mining Commission have to give reasons when it rejects an application?
For a prospecting licence, the revised Act requires reasons. For an SML rejected on the grant criteria, the Commission must give full particulars of the failure. For an ML or PML, ask in writing for the ground relied on. A refusal without a stated ground is harder to defend in court.
Can we appeal a refusal to the Minister for Minerals?
The 2019 text we read gives no general appeal to the Minister against refusal of a fresh application. The Minister sets policy and may comment on files, but the decision sits with the Commission. Ask an advocate whether any regulation creates a ministerial step for your licence class before relying on one.
How long do we have to seek judicial review of a refusal?
Leave must be sought within six months after the decision under rule 6 of GN 324 of 2014. That is an outer limit. Courts look at delay, and ground can be granted to another applicant while you wait, so instruct an advocate within weeks of the notice.
Will the court grant us the licence if we win?
No. Judicial review normally quashes the decision and sends the file back to the Commission to decide again lawfully. The court does not assess the deposit or choose between applicants. A win restores a fair process, not a guaranteed grant.
Does a rejected PML application stop the same group applying again?
No rule bars a new application. A PML refused for an overlap or a missing document can be refiled over clear ground. A PML refused because a member or director is not a citizen will fail again unless the ownership changes at BRELA first.
Can a buyer see that our application was rejected?
Applications and rights appear in the Commission's cadastre, and a buyer's advisers will search it. Keep the refusal notice, your response and proof that the defect was cured. A clean explanation in the data room avoids a price cut at diligence.
Do we lose our exploration data if the ML is refused?
The data stays yours, subject to the reporting duties already owed on the prospecting licence. Check that the PL itself is still valid, because a refused ML does not extend it. If the PL expires during the dispute, the ground may open to others.
Should we stop work on site after a refusal?
Stop any activity that needs the refused licence. Work under a valid PL may continue within its terms. Mining without the right licence is an offence, and a site raid during a dispute damages both the case and the reapplication.
Sources & regulators
Verify before filing: Rates, forms and thresholds move by Finance Act, Government Notice and portal revision. Confirm the live schedule on the mandate-holder portal before you budget or submit. Law-firm alerts and Big Four notes are discovery only.
- Mining Act, Cap. 123, revised text: TanzLII, version as at 30 November 2019. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Judicial Review Procedure and Fees) Rules, 2014, GN No. 324 of 2014: Laws.Africa, as published in 2014. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Mining (Mineral Rights) (Amendment) Regulations, 2020, GN No. 937: Geological Survey of Tanzania, 23 October 2020. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Mining Commission home page and news list: Mining Commission, 14 November 2026. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Natural Wealth and Resources (Permanent Sovereignty) Act, Cap. 449: TanzLII, version as at 14 July 2021. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Serikali yafuta leseni 40 za madini, yatoa onyo: Mwananchi, 15 April 2026. Accessed 2026-11-15.
- Leseni 74 za dhahabu zatolewa Nkasi, maombi 366 yachakatwa: JamhuriMedia, 13 October 2026. Accessed 2026-11-15.
Disclaimer
This article is informational orientation. It is not legal, tax or investment advice and not a government decision. Tanzanian instruments move by Act, Government Notice, Finance Act and portal revision. If a sentence here disagrees with the live mandate-holder, the mandate-holder wins. Zatra Consultants Limited does not issue licences, permits, tax clearances or approvals, and gives no assurance of any regulatory or banking outcome. Professional fees are published only on /pricing/.
